What is a tumor board, and how do I ask about mine?
A word like tumor board comes up mid-visit and the conversation moves on. If your case is going to one, you can ask about it. Not medical advice.
This is not clinical evidence and not medical advice. It does not replace your care team. Discuss anything here with your clinician before you act on it. Product questions are on the FAQ.
What is a tumor board?
This is not clinical evidence and not medical advice. It does not replace your care team. Discuss anything here with your clinician before you act on it. A tumor board is a meeting where cancer doctors and other specialists look at a case together and plan treatment as a group. NCI's dictionary calls it tumor board review and says the group meets regularly to go over new and complex cases. The cancer care centers' association ACCC says you may also hear multidisciplinary cancer conference. It is a team weighing a case, not a promise about treatment. ACCC adds that the treatment decision is made by the attending physician and the patient.
Who is in the room at a tumor board?
Usually several specialties, not one doctor. NCI lists medical oncologists, radiation oncologists, surgeons, pathologists, radiologists, genetics experts, nurses, physical therapists and social workers as people who can take part. Its dictionary names three primary disciplines in cancer treatment: medical oncology (drugs), surgical oncology (surgery) and radiation oncology (radiation). At programs accredited by the American College of Surgeons' Commission on Cancer, a general conference must include surgery, pathology, radiology, radiation oncology and medical oncology. Genetics, clinical research, palliative care, psychosocial, rehabilitation and supportive services are recommended additions, and programs can set their own list for a conference on one cancer type. The Commission calls these rules qualification criteria for accreditation, not a standard of care. That list is the Commission's. For any other program, a fair question for your oncologist is which specialties will look at your case.
What gets discussed at a tumor board?
Your imaging, your pathology and what to do next. MedlinePlus says doctors from different cancer specialties review x-rays, other imaging and pathology together and trade ideas on the best recommendation for you, and NCI's pathology page describes a tumor review board that looks at all of a patient's pathology results, plus any tests the pathologists ordered, together. Whether your case goes to one is a question for your team. At Commission on Cancer programs, the written protocol has to require discussing each presented case's stage and treatment planning using evidence-based guidelines. Where it applies, that also covers genetic testing, clinical research studies and supportive care. Some centers hold molecular tumor boards, which ACCC says center on biomarkers and the treatments and trials that fit tumors with them. If you have a tumor-testing report, you could ask whether the group will see it. Our page "Biomarker and genomic testing" covers what such a report is. A fair question for your team is who sends your reports and images to the board, and when. "Getting your medical records" covers how to request a copy of your file.
Which cases go to a tumor board, and does every hospital have one?
Not necessarily every case. NCI describes boards as reviewing new and complex cases. Commission on Cancer programs have a floor, not a ceiling: each year they must present at least 15 percent of their annual caseload, and at least 80 percent of those presentations must be prospective. The standard's examples of prospective cases include a new diagnosis before treatment starts, a recurrence or progression, or a discussion of supportive or palliative care. A program can hold one general conference or ones by cancer type, as long as a case that does not fit still has somewhere to go. ACCC's examples of disease-site boards are breast, lung, prostate, and head and neck. MedlinePlus says many hospitals and cancer centers have a tumor board. The government and society pages I read do not say whether every hospital has one, how clinics tell patients about their case, or whether another center's board takes outside cases. Those are questions for your team.
How often does a tumor board meet?
At Commission on Cancer programs, the standard leaves the frequency to the cancer program and its written protocol. Elsewhere, your oncologist's office can tell you. If your case is headed to a board, a fair question for your team is when the next meeting is, and whether your case is on that agenda.
How do I ask whether my case will be, or was, presented?
Consider asking your oncologist whether your case will go to a tumor board or already has. MedlinePlus notes that your doctor may already have discussed your case with other doctors, often when surgery or radiation therapy is being considered. So the conversation may have happened before you heard the term. Follow-ups can be short: Which board? Who presents it? Is it the first discussion of my case, or has it come up before?
Can another hospital's tumor board review my case?
A fair question for your team is whether your center ever sends cases to a larger center's board. What is well documented is a second opinion: NCI's dictionary defines it as another doctor reviewing your medical records and giving an opinion on how the problem should be treated. That opinion may confirm or question the first plan, add information or offer other options. The how-to lives on "Second opinions and appointments".
What is one question to ask when a tumor board comes up?
"How will I hear what the group said, and can I have it in writing?" If I were walking into that visit, I would write it at the top of my question list. For a wider list, "Questions to ask your oncologist" is the page to open. This page is not a clinical review of any treatment option, and nothing here says what a tumor board would recommend for you.
Sources
- NCI Dictionary of Cancer Terms: tumor board reviewNCI's dictionary defines tumor board review as a treatment planning process in which a group of cancer doctors and other health care specialists meet regularly to review and discuss new and complex cancer cases.
- NCI Dictionary of Cancer Terms: tumor board reviewNCI says the goal of a tumor board review is to decide as a group on the best treatment plan for a patient.
- ACCC: Tumor BoardsACCC says tumor boards are also known as multidisciplinary cancer conferences.
- NCI Dictionary of Cancer Terms: tumor board reviewNCI says tumor board meetings can involve specialists from many areas of health care, including medical oncologists, radiation oncologists, surgeons, pathologists, radiologists, genetics experts, nurses, physical therapists, and social workers.
- NCI Dictionary of Cancer Terms: multidisciplinaryNCI's dictionary says that in cancer treatment the primary disciplines are medical oncology (treatment with drugs), surgical oncology (treatment with surgery), and radiation oncology (treatment with radiation).
- American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer: Optimal Resources for Cancer Care, 2020 Standards (Standard 2.5, p. 12)The Commission on Cancer's standard says physician attendance at a general multidisciplinary cancer case conference must include a representative from surgery, pathology, radiology, radiation oncology, and medical oncology.
- American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer: Optimal Resources for Cancer Care, 2020 Standards (Standard 2.5, p. 12)The standard recommends additional physician or non-physician specialists: genetic professionals, clinical research professionals, palliative care providers, psychosocial providers, rehabilitation providers, and supportive services.
- American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer: Optimal Resources for Cancer Care, 2020 Standards (Standard 2.5, p. 12)The standard says programs may define the specialties required for specialty- or site-specific cancer case conferences.
- American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer: Optimal Resources for Cancer Care, 2020 Standards (front matter, PDF p. 6)The Commission's document says its standards are intended solely as qualification criteria for Commission on Cancer accreditation and do not constitute a standard of care.
- MedlinePlus: Your cancer diagnosis - Do you need a second opinion?MedlinePlus says that in tumor board meetings, doctors of different cancer specialties review x-rays and other imaging tests and pathology together and exchange ideas about the best recommendation to make to you.
- NCI: Surgical Pathology ReportsNCI's pathology page says that for each patient, the results of all pathology examinations and any other tests ordered by the pathologists are reviewed together by the tumor review board, a group of doctors who are experts in different specialties who plan the treatment approach for a patient.
- American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer: Optimal Resources for Cancer Care, 2020 Standards (Standard 2.5, p. 12)The Commission's standard says an accredited program's case conference protocol must include the requirement to discuss, for each case, the clinical and/or pathological stage and treatment planning using evidence-based guidelines.
- American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer: Optimal Resources for Cancer Care, 2020 Standards (Standard 2.5, p. 12)The standard adds that, where applicable, the discussion covers options and availability for genetic testing, clinical research studies, and supportive care services.
- ACCC: Tumor BoardsACCC says the treatment decision is made by the attending physician and the patient.
- ACCC: Tumor BoardsACCC says a molecular tumor board's discussion centers around molecular biomarkers and appropriate treatments and clinical trials for patients with tumors that have these markers.
- American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer: Optimal Resources for Cancer Care, 2020 Standards (Standard 2.5, p. 12)The Commission's standard says each year an accredited cancer program must present a minimum of 15 percent of its annual caseload (the standard's term is "annual analytic caseload") to a multidisciplinary cancer case conference, and that of those presented a minimum of 80 percent must be prospective presentations.
- American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer: Optimal Resources for Cancer Care, 2020 Standards (Standard 2.5, p. 12)The standard lists prospective cases as including newly diagnosed with treatment not yet initiated, or treatment initiated and discussion of additional treatment needed; previously diagnosed with discussion of adjuvant treatment or treatment for recurrence or progression needed; and previously diagnosed with discussion of supportive or palliative care needed.
- American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer: Optimal Resources for Cancer Care, 2020 Standards (Standard 2.5, p. 12)The standard says programs may hold a general multidisciplinary cancer case conference, or hold specialty- or site-specific conferences as long as there is a mechanism to present cases that do not fit the defined specialty or site.
- ACCC: Tumor BoardsACCC says disease-site-specific tumor boards focus on certain cancers, for example breast cancer, lung cancer, prostate cancer, and head and neck cancer.
- MedlinePlus: Your cancer diagnosis - Do you need a second opinion?MedlinePlus says many hospitals and cancer centers have committees called a tumor board.
- American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer: Optimal Resources for Cancer Care, 2020 Standards (Standard 2.5, p. 12)The Commission's standard says the frequency of the multidisciplinary cancer case conference is determined by the cancer program and is included in its protocol.
- MedlinePlus: Your cancer diagnosis - Do you need a second opinion?MedlinePlus says your doctor may have already discussed your case with other doctors, and that this is often the case if your doctor is considering surgery or radiation therapy as possible treatments.
- NCI Dictionary of Cancer Terms: second opinionNCI's dictionary says a second opinion is the opinion of a doctor other than the patient's current doctor, who reviews the patient's medical records and gives an opinion about the health problem and how it should be treated.
- NCI Dictionary of Cancer Terms: second opinionNCI says a second opinion may confirm or question the first doctor's diagnosis and treatment plan, give more information, and offer other treatment options.
Triangle