Cancer second opinion checklist: what to bring
What goes on a cancer second opinion checklist?
The second doctor needs the facts the first one used: the diagnosis, the evidence behind it, and the plan. ACS lists the core documents, and the table credits every row to its source. This is the checklist I would walk in with. Many insurers pay for a second opinion, and ACS suggests calling yours first, since some plans want the second opinion to come from a doctor in the plan before they will pay for cancer treatment.
| What to bring | Why it matters | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Pathology report from any biopsy or surgery | It gives the exact diagnosis the plan rests on | ACS |
| Pathology slides or paraffin block, if a second pathologist will review them | The new pathologist reads the tissue itself; the first lab or hospital releases them | NCI |
| Biomarker or molecular test reports, if you had them | They can arrive as separate reports linked to the pathology report and can help show which treatments fit | NCI |
| Copies of x-rays and scans, on film, on CD or through a patient portal | You may be asked to bring the images themselves | MedlinePlus |
| Other test results and medical records not already sent | The second doctor reviews your history and test results | MedlinePlus, NCI |
| Operative report, if you had surgery | It describes what was done during the operation | ACS |
| Discharge summary, if you were in the hospital | It is the report written when you were sent home | ACS |
| A summary of your current treatment plan | The second doctor can weigh the plan you were given | ACS, MedlinePlus |
| A list of all your medicines, with doses and when you last took each | Vitamins and supplements count too, and some medicines can have long-term side effects | ACS, MedlinePlus |
| Your questions, written down | The appointment is the time to ask them | MedlinePlus |
| A family member or friend, if you want one | Support, and a second pair of ears for the advice | MedlinePlus, NCI |
This is not clinical evidence and not medical advice. It does not replace your care team. Discuss anything here with your clinician before you act on it. Product questions are on the FAQ.
Made by Triangle.
Whether to get a second opinion, how to ask, and what to walk in with.
Should I get a second opinion after a cancer diagnosis?
Many people do get a second opinion after a cancer diagnosis. Another specialist reviews the materials in your case before treatment starts. They may agree with the plan or suggest changes. Either way you leave with more information. I did this before surgery; the list of surgeons only got short after I had read their trial histories.
When should I ask for a cancer second opinion?
ACS and MedlinePlus list much the same situations. Between them, the reasons to think seriously about a second opinion include: rare or unusual cancer; uncertainty about the type or stage, or test results that are unclear about the type and location of the cancer; several treatment options you feel unsure how to choose between, or very different recommendations; a cancer doctor who is not a specialist in your type of cancer or does not have a lot of experience treating it; thinking another treatment might be available or wanting to be sure you have explored all your options; and trouble understanding and communicating with your doctor, or discomfort with the diagnosis or plan. MedlinePlus adds that your doctor may even suggest one when the best treatment approach is not clear. ACS also notes that studies show the benefits of getting a second opinion are unclear.
Will my doctor be offended if I ask for a second opinion?
Usually not. It is common, and most doctors welcome it. ACS suggests a few ways to start, such as asking whether your doctor can recommend someone.
How do I ask for a second opinion?
You can involve your current doctor, since they have to make your records, results, and imaging available to the second one. You can say you want to be as informed as possible about your options. If they cannot suggest a specialist, NCI’s Cancer Information Service can. ACS offers a few openers if the words are hard to find, such as "Before we start treatment, I'd like to get a second opinion. Will you help me with that?" or "If you had this type of cancer, who would you see for a second opinion?"
Where can I get a cancer second opinion?
Start by asking your doctor whom they would suggest, then check the options yourself. NCI's Find a Cancer Center gives contact details for NCI-designated cancer centers across the country, and NCI's Cancer Information Service, 1-800-4-CANCER (1-800-422-6237), can help you find a specialist. Before you book, NCI suggests asking your insurance company whether the facility is approved by your plan.
Can I get a second opinion on my pathology?
Yes. NCI says a second pathologist can look at the same tissue, using the slides or paraffin block held by the pathologist or hospital that handled your biopsy or surgery. So the request goes to the pathology department where the biopsy or surgery was done, not to your oncologist's front desk. Before anything is shipped, you could check with the second institution whether it offers the review, what it costs and how it wants the samples sent. A written request that names the second institution, plus a question about who pays for shipping and when the slides come back, saves a round of calls.
Can a second opinion be done from my records alone?
You can ask. When you call the second center, you could ask whether it reviews cases from records, scans and slides without a visit, what that costs, and whether your plan covers it. If it does, send the whole checklist above, since the reviewer has only what you send. A visit adds an exam and the chance to ask questions face to face.
How long can I wait for a second opinion before starting treatment?
That depends on the cancer, so it is a question for the doctor who made the diagnosis: you can ask how long it is safe to wait before treatment starts. ACS says that for a few cancers some treatment decisions may need to be made right away, but usually you can take some time to think them through, and that if you are concerned about waiting to start treatment, you should talk to your doctor. Requesting your records, scans and slides the same week you book the second opinion keeps the wait short, because the second doctor can't review what hasn't arrived.
Is it too late for a second opinion once treatment has started?
No. MedlinePlus says you can get a second opinion even if you already had treatment, and that a second doctor can make recommendations for how your treatment will progress or may change. NCI puts it as something you may want after you talk to a doctor about the diagnosis and treatment plan, before you begin treatment. Starting treatment does not close the door.
What if the second opinion disagrees with the first?
MedlinePlus says chances are good the second opinion will be similar to the first. If it is not, you have two plans to compare, not a wrong answer to throw out. ACS suggests asking both doctors to explain how they reached their plans, how they read your test results, and which research studies or professional guidelines they used, and asking whether the two doctors can review your case together. You could also take the second report back to your first doctor or get a third opinion. A tumor board, where several specialists review a case together, is another way to work through it; see What is a tumor board. Even after a second or third opinion, MedlinePlus notes you do not have to switch doctors. You decide which doctor provides your treatment.
What should I bring to an appointment?
Every medicine you take, including over-the-counter drugs, vitamins, and supplements. A written list of questions. A short account of current conditions, past surgeries, and illnesses.
What should I ask if a test is recommended?
How it is done, how it will feel, what you need to do to prepare, and how you will get the results. If a treatment is recommended, you can ask about the options.
What should I do after the appointment?
You can ask for written instructions before you leave. If they do not make sense at home, you can call. AHRQ says not to stop a prescribed medicine without talking to your doctor or pharmacist. You can also call the office for test results and ask what to do about them.
Does asking questions make a difference?
AHRQ says patients who ask questions and make sure they understand the answers tend to get more timely, accurate diagnoses and better outcomes.
Walk into your next visit knowing your file →
Sources
- American Cancer Society: Seeking a Second OpinionHave handy for the second cancer doctor: pathology report from any biopsy or surgery, operative report if you had surgery, discharge summary if you were in the hospital, a summary of the current treatment plan, and a list of all medicines with doses and when last taken; contact your insurer first, since some plans require a second opinion from a doctor in the plan before paying for treatment; ways to start the conversation include asking your doctor to recommend someone.
- MedlinePlus: Your cancer diagnosis, do you need a second opinion?At a cancer second opinion, bring copies of medical records not already sent, including x-rays and scans on film, CD or through a patient portal; a list of all medicines including vitamins and supplements; the diagnosis and treatment your first doctor recommended; a list of questions; and a family member or friend if you wish.
- NCI: Finding Cancer Care, Getting a Second OpinionSecond opinions are very common; most doctors welcome them; many insurers pay for or require them; involve your doctor so records such as test results and x-rays can be shared; you may wish to bring a family member; NCI's Cancer Information Service can help find a specialist.
- NCI: Surgical Pathology ReportsA second opinion on pathology requires the slides or paraffin block from the pathologist or hospital; contact the institution about availability, cost, and shipping; biomarker test results may be in separate reports linked to the pathology report and can help identify treatments.
- AHRQ: Be More Engaged in Your HealthcareBring all medicines including supplements, written questions, and knowledge of your conditions; ask how a test is done, how it feels, how to prepare, and how results arrive; get written instructions; call if unclear; don't stop medicines without talking to your doctor or pharmacist; patients who ask questions tend to get more timely, accurate diagnoses.
- NCI: Finding Cancer CareNCI's Find a Cancer Center lists NCI-designated cancer centers; the Cancer Information Service at 1-800-4-CANCER (1-800-422-6237) can help; ask your insurance company whether the facility is approved by your plan (page updated August 28, 2024).
- American Cancer Society: Seeking a Second OpinionReasons for getting a second opinion include: you want to be sure you have explored all options; you have a rare or unusual cancer; you think another treatment might be available; your cancer doctor is not a specialist in the type of cancer you have; your doctor tells you there is uncertainty about the type or stage of cancer you have; your cancer doctor gives you a few different treatment options; you are having trouble understanding and communicating with your doctor.
- MedlinePlus: Your cancer diagnosis, do you need a second opinion?You should seriously think about getting a second opinion if you have been diagnosed with a rare type of cancer, received very different recommendations on how to treat it, your doctor does not have a lot of experience treating your type of cancer, you have several options and feel unsure, your test results are unclear for the type and location of your cancer, or you are not comfortable with your diagnosis or treatment plan.
- MedlinePlus: Your cancer diagnosis, do you need a second opinion?Your doctor may even recommend a second opinion when the best treatment approach for your cancer is not clear.
- American Cancer Society: Seeking a Second OpinionWhile people with cancer seem to be asking for second opinions more often, studies show the benefits of getting one are unclear.
- MedlinePlus: Your cancer diagnosis, do you need a second opinion?You can get a second opinion even if you already had treatment; a second doctor can make recommendations for how your treatment will progress or may change.
- NCI: Finding Cancer Care, Getting a Second OpinionAfter you talk to a doctor about the diagnosis and treatment plan, you may want to get another doctor's opinion before you begin treatment.
- American Cancer Society: Seeking a Second OpinionTreatment decisions should be made after you have learned all you can about your cancer; this can take time depending on the type; for a few cancers you might need to make some decisions right away, but usually you can take some time; if you are concerned about waiting to start treatment, talk to your doctor.
- American Cancer Society: Seeking a Second OpinionWays to start the conversation include: "Before we start treatment, I'd like to get a second opinion. Will you help me with that?" and "If you had this type of cancer, who would you see for a second opinion?"
- American Cancer Society: Seeking a Second OpinionIf the second opinion differs: ask both doctors to explain how they determined the treatment plans, how they interpreted your test results, and what research studies or professional guidelines they consulted, and ask if the two doctors can review your case together.
- MedlinePlus: Your cancer diagnosis, do you need a second opinion?Chances are good that the second opinion will be similar to that of your first doctor; even with a second or third opinion, you do not have to switch doctors, and you decide which doctor will provide your treatment.
Triangle