Skip to content
← Melanoma

HEALTH PROFESSIONAL · SOURCE READING

Excision

Source: Melanoma Treatment (PDQ®)–Health Professional Version, National Cancer Institute.

Source updated: May 2, 2025 · Captured 2026-09-09.

Selected source text with whitespace normalised. This Triangle page is not an NCI PDQ summary.

Context: Treatment of Stage IA Melanoma / Treatment Options for Stage IA Melanoma

No randomized controlled trials have assessed only melanomas that are less than 1 mm thick. Evidence from randomized controlled clinical trials that included patients with melanomas of this size suggests that they may be adequately treated with radial excision margins of 1 cm.

Evidence (excision):

A randomized trial that compared narrow margins (1 cm) with wide margins (≥3 cm) in 612 patients with melanomas no thicker than 2 mm included 359 patients with melanomas measuring 1 mm or less.[1,2][Level of evidence A1]

Source links and citations

A randomized trial that compared narrow margins (1 cm) with wide margins (≥3 cm) in 612 patients with melanomas no thicker than 2 mm included 359 patients with melanomas measuring 1 mm or less.[1,2][Level of evidence A1]

No difference was observed between the two groups in the development of metastatic disease, disease-free survival (DFS), or overall survival (OS).

A randomized trial that compared narrow margins (1 cm) with wide margins (≥3 cm) in 612 patients with melanomas no thicker than 2 mm included 359 patients with melanomas measuring 1 mm or less.[1,2][Level of evidence A1]

There were no local recurrences in patients with melanomas measuring 1 mm or less in either cohort.

A Swedish multicenter study included 989 patients with primary melanomas located on the trunk or extremities with a tumor thickness between 0.8 mm and 2 mm. Patients were randomly assigned to undergo wide excision with margins of 2 cm (n = 476) or 5 cm (n = 513).[3][Level of evidence A1]

Source links and citations

A Swedish multicenter study included 989 patients with primary melanomas located on the trunk or extremities with a tumor thickness between 0.8 mm and 2 mm. Patients were randomly assigned to undergo wide excision with margins of 2 cm (n = 476) or 5 cm (n = 513).[3][Level of evidence A1]

With a median follow-up of 11 years, there was no statistically significant difference in OS between the two groups.

A Swedish multicenter study included 989 patients with primary melanomas located on the trunk or extremities with a tumor thickness between 0.8 mm and 2 mm. Patients were randomly assigned to undergo wide excision with margins of 2 cm (n = 476) or 5 cm (n = 513).[3][Level of evidence A1]

With a median follow-up of 8 years, there was no statistically significant difference in recurrence-free survival between the two groups.

A Swedish multicenter study included 989 patients with primary melanomas located on the trunk or extremities with a tumor thickness between 0.8 mm and 2 mm. Patients were randomly assigned to undergo wide excision with margins of 2 cm (n = 476) or 5 cm (n = 513).[3][Level of evidence A1]

The local recurrence rate was 1%, and there was no significant difference between the treatment arms.

A European, multicenter, randomized trial compared margins of 2 cm (n = 161) versus 5 cm (n = 165) in 326 patients with primary melanomas with a thickness of 2.1 mm or less. The study included 141 patients with melanomas measuring 1 mm or less. [3,4]Level of evidence A1]

Source links and citations

A European, multicenter, randomized trial compared margins of 2 cm (n = 161) versus 5 cm (n = 165) in 326 patients with primary melanomas with a thickness of 2.1 mm or less. The study included 141 patients with melanomas measuring 1 mm or less. [3,4]Level of evidence A1]

There was no statistically significant difference in 10-year DFS or OS between the two groups.

A European, multicenter, randomized trial compared margins of 2 cm (n = 161) versus 5 cm (n = 165) in 326 patients with primary melanomas with a thickness of 2.1 mm or less. The study included 141 patients with melanomas measuring 1 mm or less. [3,4]Level of evidence A1]

Local recurrence occurred in one patient treated with a 2-cm margin and four patients treated with 5-cm margins.

Continue within this section

Publication references

Read the original reference and check its publication notices.

Preserved source evidence · Not medical advice