How to appeal a health insurance denial
If your health insurance plan refuses to pay a claim or ends your coverage, you have the right to appeal the denial. They have to tell you why, and how to dispute it. Two stages: an internal appeal inside the insurer, then, if that fails, an external review by an independent third party whose decision the insurer must accept.
This is not clinical evidence and not medical advice. It does not replace your care team. Discuss anything here with your clinician before you act on it. Product questions are on the FAQ.
Made by Triangle.
A denial is a letter, not a verdict. You get an internal appeal and then an independent review, each with deadlines that run both ways.
How does an internal appeal work?
They must notify you in writing and explain why: within 15 days if you were seeking prior authorization, 30 days for services already received, or 72 hours for urgent care. You then have 180 days from that notice to file. You can use their forms, or write with your name, claim number, and insurance ID, and attach anything you want considered; a letter from your doctor is the usual one. Your state’s Consumer Assistance Program can file for you.
They must finish the internal appeal within 30 days if the service has not happened yet, or 60 days if it has. The decision comes in writing. If they still say no, that letter has to tell you how to request an external review.
Common reasons, all appealable: the benefit is not in your plan, the service was out of network, they called the treatment not medically necessary, they called it experimental or investigational, or they claim you are no longer eligible.
How does an external review work?
You request it in writing within four months of the final denial. Denials that involve medical judgment, that call a treatment experimental or investigational, and coverage cancellations based on claimed misinformation can all go here. Standard review: 45 days. Expedited: 72 hours or less, depending on urgency. The reviewer’s decision binds the insurer. Federal process: no charge. Otherwise the fee is capped at $25 per review.
Urgent cases get a faster track. When the usual wait could seriously put your life, or your ability to regain maximum function, at risk, you can ask for an expedited appeal and request the external review alongside the internal one instead of after it. HealthCare.gov says the final answer then has to arrive as fast as your condition needs, no later than four business days.
Who regulates my plan?
It decides where a complaint goes. If your employer pays claims directly instead of buying insurance (a self-funded or self-insured plan), the US Department of Labor says the plan generally isn’t subject to state health insurance laws. ERISA sets its claims and appeal rules instead, and the Labor Department’s Employee Benefits Security Administration answers questions at 1-866-444-3272. If you’re not sure whether ERISA applies to you, the Labor Department suggests asking your plan administrator. Coverage through an HMO or an insurance policy generally follows state rules.
The Labor Department says that if your coverage is offered through an HMO or an insurance policy, you can check with your state insurance department for more information on that state’s insurance laws. Some states split the job. In California, for example, the Department of Managed Health Care oversees all HMOs in the state and some other kinds of plans; its Help Center is at 1-888-466-2219. The Department of Insurance handles PPO and EPO policies from the insurers it licenses, though DMHC handles some PPOs and EPOs too. CDI says it doesn’t regulate HMOs, some PPOs, self-insured plans, or Medicare and Medi-Cal coverage. If you can’t tell which office is yours, CDI’s hotline at 1-800-927-4357 will point you to the right place, and in many states a Consumer Assistance Program can help.
Medicare Advantage plans follow Medicare’s own appeal levels and must tell you in writing how to appeal. For Medi-Cal managed care in California, the state’s Department of Health Care Services runs an Office of the Ombudsman (1-888-452-8609) that helps members solve problems with their plans.
Medi-Cal managed care members can also ask the California Department of Social Services for a State Hearing at 1-800-743-8525. CDSS says they generally must first appeal to their plan, then have 120 calendar days from the plan’s Notice of Appeal Resolution to ask, or can ask if that notice hasn’t arrived within 30 days of the appeal.
What paperwork should I keep?
Explanation of Benefits showing the denial. Your appeal request. Anything from your doctor. Any authorization letting someone file for you. Notes from every phone call: date, time, name, title. Copies go out; originals stay with you. This is the kind of pile that is easier if your records and letters already live in one place.
If you’d rather not file yourself, a representative can take the external review on your behalf; that is often your doctor. Help at either stage is also available from your state’s Consumer Assistance Program or Department of Insurance.
See how Triangle keeps your records and letters in one place for the appeal →
Sources
- HealthCare.gov: How to appeal an insurance company decisionYou have a right to an internal appeal and to an external review; insurers must explain denials and how to dispute them; external review takes the final say away from the insurer.
- HealthCare.gov: Internal appealsDenial notice timing (15 days prior authorization, 30 days services received, 72 hours urgent); 180 days to file an internal appeal; what to submit; Consumer Assistance Programs can file; internal appeal decided within 30 or 60 days; common denial reasons; expedited appeals decided within 4 business days; documents to keep.
- HealthCare.gov: External ReviewExternal review must be requested within 4 months; types of denials eligible; decided within 45 days (standard) or 72 hours (expedited); binding on insurer; no charge under the federal process, otherwise capped at $25; a representative may file for you; state Consumer Assistance Programs help.
- US Department of Labor (EBSA): Technical Release No. 2014-01In general, private sector employment-based group health plans that self-insure are not subject to State health insurance laws, including coverage laws, rating policies, and certain other State consumer protections applicable to health insurance.
- US Department of Labor (EBSA): Filing a Claim for Your Health BenefitsERISA sets claims and appeal rules for private-sector employment health plans; if you’re not sure whether ERISA applies, contact your plan administrator; EBSA benefits advisors at 1-866-444-3272.
- US Department of Labor (EBSA): Health Coverage Portability (HIPAA) Compliance FAQsState laws related to health insurance issuers generally continue to apply; if health coverage is offered through an HMO or an insurance policy, check with your State insurance department.
- California DMHC: Types of PlansThe Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) oversees all HMOs in California and some other kinds of health plans; DMHC Help Center 1-888-466-2219.
- California Department of Insurance: Health Insurance RegulationCDI regulates companies selling health insurance in California but does not regulate health plans (HMOs), some PPOs, self-insured plans, and Medicare/Medi-Cal coverage; its Consumer Hotline 1-800-927-4357 helps people find who to contact.
- California Department of Insurance: Types of Health CoveragePPO and EPO members contact CDI for help; in some cases DMHC regulates PPOs and handles EPOs; if not sure who to call, CDI’s hotline (1-800-927-4357) will help you get to the right place; HMO members contact DMHC.
- CMS: Consumer Assistance ProgramMany states offer help to consumers with health insurance problems through Consumer Assistance Programs (CAPs).
- Medicare.gov: Filing an appealIf you are in a Medicare Advantage plan, check your plan materials or contact your plan for your appeal rights; the plan must tell you, in writing, how to appeal; Medicare appeals generally have 5 levels.
- California DHCS: Medi-Cal Managed Care and Mental Health Office of the OmbudsmanThe Medi-Cal Managed Care and Mental Health Office of the Ombudsman helps solve problems between Medi-Cal managed care members and managed care plans; phone (888) 452-8609.
- California Department of Social Services: State Hearing RequestsIf you disagree with an action taken by your Medi-Cal managed care plan, you generally must first file an appeal with your managed care plan; you have 120 calendar days from the plan’s Notice of Appeal Resolution to request a state hearing, or may request one if no Notice of Appeal Resolution arrives within 30 days; State Hearings Division toll-free (800) 743-8525.
Triangle